A lively, almost Cabernet Franc like nose that entices one to dive deeper. You’ll love this wine for its ability to display its black fruit, white pepper and currant profile without being flashy—meaning it’s elegantly subdued with a lot going on; great tannin structure without being too obtrusive with a good oak regimen. Pair this with grilled red meats, or even better, a heavily peppered beef carpaccio. For my vegetarian friends, slow cooked, rich root vegetables would work well, which would enhance the richness of the wine, and the sweetness of the vegetables. The bottom line is that this is an affordable Cabernet Sauvignon worthy of attention—it is a $45 bargain from the Napa Valley. ~Pamela Heiligenthal
One whiff after you uncork this wine and you will know this one will need a moment to collect its composure and show its full and welcomed presence, sort of like regaining ones sea legs. Subtle and elegant—now that’s two great words seldom used these days. This wine has complexity and depth that is wasted on a lot of audiences not from the school of thought that good things only come to pass with the proper time and most importantly the proper respect. Without proper respect many would have consumed this wine and never known the intense package that lay just beneath the surface waiting for a little bit more time to reveal its luxurious fullness. Big aromas and flavors to match, the 2005 Smith–Madrone Cabernet Sauvignon stands tall among the immense competition for this varietal from this AVA. ~Marc Hinton
Rating: Excellent (90) | $45 | 14.2% ABV
Find this wine to buy: Vinquire | WineZap.com



Chef says, Somm says…how original and cute! Love the format guys!
Thanks Karen, cheers!
This wine sounds absolutely wonderful from both perspectives!
:) appreciate the comment JJ!
Great review what a refreshing change to hear both the front and back of the house views. I think most diners forget about the option of asking the chef their opinion of which wine may pair best with their recipes. Smith-Madrone sounds like a wine worth seeking out.
Great observation Austin, appreciate the comment.
Hello.This post was extremely remarkable, especially since I was looking for this post since last Saturday!
Sounds delicious. By the way, I like the new somm versus chef review format.
This is a producer I have not heard of. I’m excited to try this wine, and as always, thanks for the great information.